| Name | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 |
| 3.14 | SAFE | LOSE | WIN | WIN | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | WIN | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | WIN | WIN | WINNER | |
| McBoo | SAFE | LOSE | WIN | WIN | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | WIN | SAFE | WIN | LOSE | LOSE | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | RUNNER - UP | |
| Clyde | SAFE | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | LOSE | OUT | ||
| Purple Koopa Bro | SAFE | LOSE | WIN | WIN | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | OUT | |||
| Pesh | SAFE | WIN | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | WIN | SAFE | OUT | |||
| Henry The Moose | SAFE | WIN | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | LOSE | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | WIN | OUT | GUEST | ||||
| YoshiEgg Nook | SAFE | WIN | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | SAFE | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | WIN | OUT | GUEST | ||||
| Tulip Nook | AUDIENCE | WIN | WIN | WIN | LOSE | SAFE | LOSE | LOSE | OUT | GUEST | |||||||||||
| Fire Master | AUDIENCE | WIN | WIN | WIN | LOSE | SAFE | LOSE | OUT | GUEST | ||||||||||||
| Nightwolf | AUDIENCE | WIN | WIN | WIN | LOSE | SAFE | OUT | GUEST | |||||||||||||
| Hiro The Echidna | AUDIENCE | LOSE | LOSE | LOSE | OUT | GUEST | |||||||||||||||
| Ginourm | AUDIENCE | LOSE | LOSE | OUT | GUEST | ||||||||||||||||
| Xero | AUDIENCE | LOSE | OUT | GUEST | |||||||||||||||||
| Moyan | SAFE | LOSE | WIN | WIN | WIN | LOSE | OUT | GUEST | |||||||||||||
| Heart | SAFE | LOSE | WIN | WIN | WIN | OUT | GUEST | ||||||||||||||
| Hark | SAFE | WIN | LOSE | LOSE | OUT | HOST | |||||||||||||||
| Ybrik | SAFE | WIN | LOSE | OUT | HOST | ||||||||||||||||
| Chaos 12 | SAFE | WIN | OUT | GUEST | |||||||||||||||||
| Flame | SAFE | OUT | GUEST |